The Real Talk on Root Caries
Okay, let’s just admit it. We’re all seeing it. That mushy, brownish spot right at the gum line that just gives you a bad feeling. It’s not the good old-fashioned occlusal decay we got so good at fixing in dental school.
Nope. This is a different beast entirely. Root caries. And it’s becoming the bane of our existence.
For decades, the whole game was about enamel. The hard stuff. The crown. We built our entire philosophy around protecting and patching it up. But the rules have changed right under our noses. Our patients are actually keeping their teeth, which should be a victory lap for us, right? But the prize for winning that game is a brand new, much tougher one: defending exposed tooth roots.
When we’re talking about root caries lesions, we’re talking about decay on a surface that was never supposed to be in the fight. Cementum. Dentin. It’s soft. It’s porous. And it dissolves in a light breeze compared to enamel. The second you get recession, from perio or from a patient scrubbing their gums into oblivion, that vulnerable surface is out in the open. A sitting duck.
The ADA has been waving the flag on this, sure. But the guidelines feel like they’re miles behind what’s actually walking through our doors every day. We see the problem, but our old toolbox feels half-empty. This isn’t just about drilling and filling anymore. It’s about managing a chronic, messy disease in patients who are already dealing with a dozen other things.
NEWSLETTER
Get expert guidance and new breakthroughs in dentistry delivered straight to your inbox.
It’s Not Your Imagination. It’s an Epidemic.
We’re not making this up. The schedule is full of it. The prevalence of root caries is exploding. Why? Well, we did our jobs too well. People are old enough to have gray hair and still have their own teeth. A generation ago, that was an anomaly. Now it’s just… Tuesday. But all that extra time means baggage. Decades of chewing, weird diets, medications, life. It’s a perfect storm.
And the risk factors? It’s basically a description of half our patient base. Yeah, poor oral hygiene is on the list. But that’s the easy answer. The real knockout punch is dry mouth. Saliva is the great protector, and when it’s gone, the whole defense system just shuts down. Why is it gone? Meds. How many of our older folks aren’t on a fistful of prescriptions for blood pressure, cholesterol, you name it? That, or other medical issues.
So yeah, older adults are ground zero. They’ve got the trifecta: decreased salivary flow, receding gums, and probably a few root caries lesions already brewing.
But hold on. It’s not just them.
Anyone with hands too stiff to hold a brush, a sweet tooth, or a history of head and neck radiation, they’re all in the club. The WHO is right to call this a public health problem, but that sounds so distant. For us, it’s a clinical epidemic that ends in extractions if we’re not smart and aggressive. It’s a mess, and telling someone to just “brush more” is, frankly, an insult to the complexity of what they’re facing.
It’s More Than Just Dry Mouth: Other Risk Factors in Play
So we all know that reduced salivary flow is the big bad wolf here. But if we stop there, we’re missing half the story. The increased tooth retention in the worldwide population means we’re dealing with decades of habits baked into our patients’ lives, and some of them are just brutal for exposed root surfaces.
Let’s talk diet. Not in a vague “eat your vegetables” way. I’m talking about the specifics of dietary habits that fuel dental caries. The constant sipping on sugary coffee, the “healthy” snack bars loaded with sticky fermentable carbohydrates. It’s a continuous acid bath. We have to be blunt about changing dietary habits. The fight against the caries process isn’t just about what they eat, but how often. This isn’t like the old days of just fighting coronal caries after a candy binge; this is a slow, grinding war on dentin.
And what about tobacco use? We know it trashes gums and causes root exposure, but it also creates a perfect storm for the dental biofilm to thrive. Then you have other medical conditions that might not cause dry mouth but affect dexterity or cognitive function. Suddenly, even the best intentions for good oral health fall apart. These other risk factors create a cumulative effect, dramatically increasing the risk for the geriatric population, where managing even one factor is a challenge, let alone a handful of them.
Active or Arrested? That is the Question.
At its heart, the biology is the same old song. Bacteria, sugar, acid, demineralization. But the where changes everything. Root surfaces don’t have enamel armor. They start dissolving at a pH of 6.7, while enamel holds on ‘til 5.5. This means the root is under acid attack almost constantly in a high-risk mouth.
This is where our clinical spidey-sense has to kick in. You have to know the difference between an active root caries lesion and an inactive one. Everything hinges on this call. The active ones? They’re soft. Leathery. Your explorer just sinks in a little. They’re usually a pale yellow or light brown, hiding right where the biofilm is thickest. These are the fires we have to put out. Now.
An inactive, or arrested, lesion is totally different. It’s hard as a rock. Smooth. Usually dark brown or black. It’s a scar from a previous battle the mouth actually won. Maybe the patient’s diet changed, maybe they finally got on a prescription fluoride paste. Who knows. These, we can usually watch. The problem, of course, is that they can wake up. Our job isn’t just to spot the hole; it’s to be a detective. Why did this one stop? What changed? Getting that answer is gold. And that’s our opening to talk about the heavy hitters, like fluoride varnishes or the big one everyone’s talking about, silver diamine fluoride.
“Just Brush and Floss” Isn’t Cutting It
Of course, it all comes back to oral hygiene. It has to. We can place a flawless restoration, but if the patient can’t get the plaque off of it, we’re just delaying the inevitable. Brushing, flossing, Waterpiks, interproximal brushes, whatever it takes. It’s not negotiable.
But here’s the rub. The patients who need that meticulous hygiene the most are often the least capable of doing it. Arthritis. Shaky hands. Failing eyesight. Dementia. These aren’t excuses; they’re genuine barriers. A toothbrush and a pamphlet isn’t a plan. It’s a surrender. We have to be creative. A fatter handle on the brush? A power brush that does the work for them? We have to problem-solve with them, not lecture at them.
This is where our hygienists are doing the lord’s work. They’re the ones in the trenches, doing the coaching, the customizing, the cheerleading. They’re the ones turning that vague advice into something a patient can actually do. It’s not about clean teeth. It’s about survival.
Patient Education and Existing Root Caries
We can know all this until we’re blue in the face. But if the patient is tuned out, we lose. Patient education isn’t just a nice thing to do; it’s probably our most critical procedure. And it can’t be the mumbled, rushed two-minute spiel while we’re stripping our gloves off.
They need to get it. They need to see the recession in the mirror. They need to understand that a dry mouth isn’t just uncomfortable, it’s catastrophic for their teeth. They need to connect that morning soda habit to the reason they might need a denture. We have to drop the dental-speak. We say “xerostomia,” and we’ve lost them. They hear Charlie Brown’s teacher. We say “periodontal disease,” they hear “my gums bleed sometimes, no big deal.”
We have to talk about consequences. Real ones. This is the difference between eating a steak and eating soup for the rest of their lives. That’s the kind of patient awareness we need to build. Give them a simple, clear mission. “Use this toothpaste.” “Sip this water.” “Avoid that drink.” It’s the only way.
The Game Plan: Prevention and Oral Hygiene
Prevention isn’t an action; it’s a full-court press. Baseline is good hygiene and smart food choices. But for the folks on our high-risk list, that’s just the warm-up. We have to bring in the cavalry.
And that means fluoride. Lots of it. The ADA backs this up. Forget the over-the-counter stuff. These patients need the 5000-ppm prescription paste, period. They need professional fluoride varnish slathered on every three or four months. Yeah, just like the kids. This needs to be our standard of care.
We have other plays, too. Chlorhexidine varnishes? The jury’s still out on how great they are, but they have a role. Xylitol gum or lozenges can help. The point is, you layer the defenses. You look at any systematic review, and it’s clear: there is no magic bullet. It’s the combo of what we do in the office, what they do at home, and the behavioral changes that actually works. We’re building a fortress.
Okay, It’s Here. Now What?
So what happens when the fortress is breached and you’re staring at a soft, active spot? This is where the art and science of dentistry really clash. The old-school reflex is to grab the handpiece. See decay, remove decay.
Stop.
That’s often the wrong move with root caries. The first question out of our mouths should be: “Can I stop this without drilling?” Is the spot cleansable? Is the patient even a little bit motivated? Can we change the environment? If there’s a flicker of a “yes,” then non-invasive treatments have to be Plan A. And that’s a huge mental shift for us. We were trained to be fixers. Carpenters. Now we have to be physicians.
Sometimes, though, you have to cut. The cavitation is a plaque trap. It looks awful and the patient hates it. The non-invasive stuff failed. Fine. We intervene. But the goal is just to stop the train from going off the rails and make it cleansable. It’s a constant tightrope walk.
When You Have to Drill: The Ugly Reality
Restoring these is nothing like a nice, clean Class I. It’s a mess. They’re weird, saucer-shaped lesions in a swamp. Getting isolation is a joke. Bonding to dentin is a prayer. Your material choice is everything.
Glass ionomer is the ugly workhorse for a reason. It bonds to the tooth, and it releases fluoride. It’s not winning any beauty contests, but on a lower second molar root, who cares? Function over form.
Composite resins? Sure, if it’s a Class V on #8 and the patient has a Hollywood audition. But you better be a superhero with your isolation. If that margin gets even a little damp, you’ll be replacing that filling, and the recurrent decay under it, in a year. It’s a high-wire act with no net.
The Messy Middle Ground of Restorative Treatment
Okay, so sometimes drilling is unavoidable. But our conventional approach often feels like bringing a cannon to a knife fight. This is where we need to think about a more nuanced restorative treatment. I’m talking about things like atraumatic restorative treatment (ART). It sounds fancy, but it’s basically a “scoop and fill” philosophy—remove the soft, mushy decay with hand instruments and restore with a material that actively helps the tooth.
This is where glass ionomer cement (GIC) really shines. We already know it’s our go-to for these swampy preps. It releases fluoride, it chemically bonds to dentin, and it’s way more forgiving than composite. Yeah, you’re not getting a perfect shade match, so it’s not the top choice for Class V restorations on #9 where aesthetic improvement is the main goal. But for restoring root caries lesions on a posterior tooth? It’s a no-brainer. It’s about preserving the tooth’s structural integrity, not winning a beauty contest. The British Dental Journal has published some compelling evidence on GIC’s effectiveness in managing root caries, especially in the high-risk elderly population. It’s a practical solution for a messy problem.
The whole point is to be less invasive. We’re not just filling a hole; we’re trying to stop the dentine demineralisation and make the area cleansable to prevent future tooth decay.
The “Magic” of Not Drilling and Managing Root Caries
This is the big one. The shift that feels both exciting and terrifying. Non-invasive management. It’s about treating the disease, not just the symptom. It’s about putting the drill down.
And the poster child for this is silver diamine fluoride (SDF). It’s not new, but for most of us, it feels like it. And for some of our most challenging patients (the elderly, the medically complex, the nursing home residents) it’s a godsend. It kills the bugs and hardens the tooth. One drop. Done. You can literally stop a cavity in 30 seconds.
The catch? It’s a big one. It turns the decay jet black. And it’s permanent. You absolutely have to have that conversation. But you frame it like this: “Which is worse, a small black spot on a back tooth you can’t see, or losing the whole tooth?” The answer is usually pretty obvious. It’s not pretty, but it works.
Failure.
That’s what it feels like sometimes, doesn’t it? When you have no choice but to pick up the handpiece. When the lesion is just too big, too deep, the tooth is about to snap. That’s invasive management. Our world. Drilling and filling.
But even here, we have to be different. We have to be delicate. Minimal. We are working on a fragile root, inches from the pulp. Going in like a cowboy is a great way to cause a world of hurt and end up doing endo.
This choice, to cut or not to cut, is one of the hardest we make. The temptation to just “get it done” with a filling is huge. It feels final. Definitive. But every time we drill, we start that clock on the restorative death spiral. Replacement, more tooth structure gone, another replacement. We have to see it as the last resort.
The Gut-Check: Making the Call for Oral Health
So how do you decide? There’s no flowchart that works. It’s a gut call based on a dozen factors.
What does the lesion look like? Active? Cavitated? Can they even clean it? And who is this person in your chair? What’s their risk? Their health? Their dexterity? Do they even care?
The research can give us odds, but it can’t make the call for us. SDF might be a home run for the 85-year-old with Parkinson’s. A perfectly bonded composite might be the right call for the healthy 50-year-old who just has one problem spot.
And for God’s sake, talk to the patient. Lay out the options. The good, the bad, the ugly. “We can drill it and fill it, and it will look nice, but it’s tricky. Or, we can paint this on, it will turn black, but it will stop the decay cold.” That’s real informed consent.
The Bottom Line for Dental Caries
So, what do we do on Monday? What’s the takeaway?
- First, we have to get serious about patient education. Make it the main event, not the closing act.
- Second, we have to get comfortable being uncomfortable. That means embracing things like SDF and resisting that urge to just drill everything. We’re disease managers now. Get used to it.
- Third, one size fits none. Every patient, every tooth is a unique puzzle. If you’re not customizing your approach, you’re not doing your job.
- And finally, we have to get out of our silo. Call the patient’s doctor about the meds causing dry mouth. Talk to the caregiver. Root caries isn’t just a tooth problem; it’s a person problem.
The whole thing is a massive challenge. No doubt. But we have the tools. We just have to be willing to change our thinking. The old way isn’t going to cut it anymore.
Closing Thoughts
At the end of the day, the explosion in the prevalence of root caries has fundamentally changed our job. We’re not just tooth carpenters anymore. Our role has shifted to being chronic disease managers, part detective, and part behavioral coach. It’s frustrating. It’s messy. And some days it feels like we’re losing.
But it’s also some of the most important work we can do. Preventing root caries and finding creative ways to manage existing lesions is how we help people keep their natural teeth and maintain their quality of life as they navigate old age. It’s about ensuring our patients don’t face tooth loss simply because they’ve had the good fortune of a long life. The challenge is huge, thanks to things like increasing life expectancy, but that’s what makes it meaningful. So yeah, it’s a different beast. But we’re the ones who are here to tame it.
References:
[1] Qutieshat, A., Salem, A., Aouididi, R., Delatorre Bronzato, J., Al-Waeli, H., Abufadalah, M., Shaikh, S., Yassir, Y., Mhanni, A., Vasantavada, P., & Amer, H. (2021). Perspective and practice of root caries management: a multicountry study – Part I. Journal of conservative dentistry : JCD, 24(2), 141–147. https://doi.org/10.4103/jcd.jcd_19_21
